My John D. Rockefeller Jr.
Library Fellowship took place between October 10 and December 14, 2015. I lived in Williamsburg in an eighteenth-century
dwelling near the Duke of Gloucester Street for two months and immersed myself in the sights,
sounds, resources and experiences afforded to me through this unique
opportunity. Due to roof construction,
I worked from the Bruton Heights School Education Center rather than from the top
floor of the Rockefeller Library but much enjoyed meeting staff members from
different departments in the process. There is something great that happens
when one does not need to go into a long preamble about one’s research. At Colonial Williamsburg (CW),
people got it: they grasped and embraced what my research was about and that
was part of the magic.
I worked in collaboration with CW staff members Michael
McCarty, Apprentice Tailor, and his supervisor, Mark D. Hutter, Tailor. Their
exhaustive knowledge of eighteenth-century men’s fashion is key to investigate
Euro-American menswear from the 1760s and 1770s in order to re-assess the Macaroni.
I proposed to them that we write an article about this subject that could
translate into a juried conference proposal. As first author, I would share the
research I had accumulated on the subject before my Fellowship began and
investigate new leads, read the current literature on the topic, organize
meetings, keep track of our discussions, propose an organizational structure,
investigate scholarly journals to send the article to, write the first draft,
make revisions following their review, send the article to the chosen journal,
consult with them to make revisions proposed by the journal’s editor and bring
the article to completion. As Mr. McCarty had done research on the subject, he
would be the second author and would share his research findings and
investigate new leads, take part in meetings and in research appointments to
look at CW artifacts and edit the first draft and subsequent editorial
revisions. Mr. Hutter, being busy with the Washington Tent project during the
first month of my Fellowship, would act as third author. He would join our
meetings and research outings when he could, contribute findings if he had time
to do so and read and contribute his advance knowledge to written documents. We
agreed to proceed and brainstormed about what we all knew to meet the Costume
Society of America’s October 16 deadline for oral presentation proposals for
their May 2016 Symposium.
I spent the weeks
that followed reading scholarly articles, chapters in books, one monograph and
meeting with my collaborators. While this was not enough time to cover the
literature and more will occur in coming months, cross-disciplinary readings
were useful to reexamine key terms and concepts that changed my perception of
texts discussing the Macaroni. For example Philip Carter’s 1997 article
for Textual Practice entitled “An
‘effeminate’ or ‘efficient’ nation? Masculinity and eighteenth‐century
social documentary” was extremely helpful to untangle period understanding and
concerns about effeminacy as a social conduct believed to stem from a rise in
luxury and its affiliated consumption rather than sexual behavior (Carter 1997,
429-430). A grasp of the political, economic and social changes occurring in
Britain in the 1760s is also essential to observe the members of London’s “Maccaroni Club”[sic]
described in 1764 by Horace Walpole as “travelled young men who wear long curls
and spying-glasses.”[1]
This urban set may have followed a new refined model of masculinity at odds
with changing British self-perception (Rauser 2004). This model was likely
rooted in continental manners acquired through increased elite travel across
Europe on the “Grand Tour” following Britain’s success in the Seven Years War
(1756-1763). As such, the Macaroni phenomenon is at a crossroad within British
culture and is also at the height of its popularity when the War for American
Independence begins.
Midway through my residency, on November 5, I gave a
presentation to CW staff at the Bruton Heights School Education Center as registrations
exceeded the capacity of the conference room at the Rockefeller Library. With the help of a
PowerPoint, I discussed the state of knowledge on the Macaroni, problems of
interpretation that need to be addressed and questions that remain to be
answered. I much appreciated the diversity of
researchers in the audience—from historians and video-producers on staff, to
milliners and wigmakers in the historic trade department—and their feedback. The
timing of the presentation allowed me to narrow down our focus and meet
individuals whose work linked with my own.
During the second half of the Fellowship I tried to reach
out to many CW researchers in several departments. I had meetings with my
collaborators and Linda Baumgarten, Textile and Costume Curator, to look at
clothing artifacts; Margaret Pritchard, Senior Curator and Curator, Prints,
Maps, and Wallpaper, to observe and photograph 1760s-1780s caricatures;
Elizabeth Myers, Journeyman Wigmaker, to better understand men’s wigs, which
are an important feature in Macaroni caricatures; Janea Whitacre, Mistress
Milliner and Mantua-maker, to discuss female Macaronis for a potential
follow-up to the current research on a phenomenon that is mostly described as
male; and Stewart Pittman, Drum Instructor for the Fifes and Drums to
investigate the history of the song “Yankee Doodle Dandy.” Through the
suggestion of Janea Whitaker, I also reached out to staff members at the print
shop to better understand the context in which Darly Macaroni prints were
produced and Acts of Parliament they abided by. The combined knowledge of a
variety of CW researchers was invaluable to the project.
In conclusion, my two months Fellowship was both
extremely pleasant and productive. Friendships were made or strengthened and a
template for future collaborations is underway with the present research
project. In addition to the article planned, different facets of the research
will be disseminated in two 2016 scholarly conferences: the first is a combined
presentation in May at the Costume Society of America Symposium in Cleveland
and the second a solo presentation—proposed before my CW arrival—for the
international Pasold conference “Dressing Global Bodies” at the University of
Alberta in Edmonton in July. Both will address the materials covered in the
article and will enable us to receive feedback before the article is completed
and sent to a journal at the end of the summer. I think the research would also
make a wonderful exhibition and a proposal is bound to follow.
[1] Horace Walpole’s Correspondence, The Lewis Walpole Library, Yale
University, Letter to the Earl of
Hertford, 6 Feb. 1764, http://images.library.yale.edu/hwcorrespondence/page.asp?vol=38 page=306
(accessed October 14, 2015).

No comments:
Post a Comment